The term
“Big Five” is synonymous with hunting and safaris in Africa.
Many wildlife reserves will use the term ‘Big Five Reserve’ to proclaim the
fact that they have Lion, Leopard, Elephant, Buffalo and Rhino on the property.
Black Rhino |
Sadly, many visitors to
this region are only interested in seeing those five species. They tick them
off and return home happy – oblivious to the remarkable diversity of wildlife
that they didn’t see.
Now I have nothing against the Big Five - they are
wonderful creatures and are not called the Big Five for nothing – but they are
just five examples of the remarkable diversity of mammals present in Africa.
However I would love this
all to change, which is the purpose of this post. I’d like to encourage all
wildlife enthusiasts to get excited about seeing our SECRET SEVENTEEN mammals. Why
seventeen? Well, there is no compelling reason why it has to be seventeen. It
could just have easily been the Secret Sixteen or perhaps the Elusive Eighteen.
The Furtive Fifteen came to mind as did the Nocturnal Nineteen – but the
adjectives ‘elusive’, ‘furtive’ and ‘nocturnal’ weren’t universally
appropriate.
Aardvark |
I’ve
compiled the list that follows from mammals occurring in South Africa
but there is no reason why the concept should just be a South African one. All
countries should have their own version of the SECRET SEVENTEEN. Each country has
its own wonderful endemic species that should be included in its national list.
My
guidelines for selecting a proposed list of seventeen secretive species were as
follows:
1. They
shouldn’t be easily seen, but should nevertheless be capable of being seen with
some effort.
2. They
should have a reasonably wide distribution within the country. Species that
only occur at the margins of South
Africa might be rare but are not appropriate
for this list. So something like the Suni (Neotragus
moschatus) might be rare enough in South Africa but is widespread in
Mozambique – so is excluded.
Riverine Rabbit |
Similarly, the Riverine Rabbit (Bunolagus monticularis) now only exists
in such isolated pockets that the likelihood of most people seeing one is very
slim.
I have also favoured those rare species that occur in the traditional ‘game viewing’ regions of this country because that is where most visitors go to view wildlife.
I have also favoured those rare species that occur in the traditional ‘game viewing’ regions of this country because that is where most visitors go to view wildlife.
Small-Spotted Genet |
3. Where there are closely related species of a particular family, that are all worthy of inclusion, then I have simply included the generic family.
For example, any one of the three species of genet occurring here could have been chosen so I’ve decided to include just ‘Genets’ on the list.
The same goes for our two Otters and two Galagos (Bushbabies).
4. However,
in contrast to the above, there are some families with both rare and abundant
representatives e.g. Mongoose, where we have ten - I think. Here I’ve made a decision to include just one
species which I think best fits my other criteria.
5. I’ve
excluded those Orders/Families that are particularly difficult to identify (and
possibly of lesser interest to the general wildlife-viewing public). These
would include the small rodents, moles, bats and marine mammals. I appreciate
that I’m now on dangerous ground! I know that there are many extraordinary examples
of the above but most wildlife enthusiasts, and even guides, wouldn’t be
capable of identifying them without catching them.
Brown Hyena |
6. I’ve
also excluded large mammals which might be fairly rare but, if they occur in
the area/reserve, are usually easy to see during the day. Examples would be Roan (Hippotragus equinus) and Sable (H. niger) Antelopes.
So here
goes. This is my suggested list – in alphabetic order:
1
|
Aardvark
|
Orycteropus
afer
|
2
|
Aardwolf
|
Proteles
cristatus
|
3
|
African
Civet
|
Civettictis
civetta
|
4
|
African
Weasel
|
Poecilogale
albinucha
|
5
|
African
Wild Cat
|
Felis
silvestris lybica
|
6
|
Brown
Hyena
|
Parahyaena
brunnea
|
7
|
Bushpig
|
Potamochoerus
larvatus
|
8
|
Caracal
|
Caracal
caracal
|
9
|
Galagos
(Bushbabies)
|
Galago
moholi; Otolemur crassicaudatus
|
10
|
Genets
|
Genetta
genetta, G maculata, G tigria
|
11
|
Honey Badger
|
Mellivora
capensis
|
12
|
Otters
|
Lutra
maculicollis, Aonyx capensis
|
13
|
Pangolin
|
Manis
temminckii
|
14
|
Porcupine
|
Hystrix
africaeaustralis
|
15
|
Serval
|
Leptailurus
serval
|
16
|
Southern
African Hedgehog
|
Atelerix
frontalis
|
17
|
White-Tailed
Mongoose
|
Ichneumia
albicauda
|
This is a
very personal selection and I’m very aware that some worthy species have been
excluded. So I would really welcome your
suggestions as to what would be other appropriate inclusions to this list, or
simply your preferences. As mentioned above, this is my South African
selection. So if you’re not from South Africa I’d also love to hear
what your SECRET SEVENTEEN would be in other countries. Please do respond – I’d
love to hear what you think.
African Wild Cat |
p.s. So when you do go out and find these secretive species please do take a photo and send it to the University of Cape Towns's MammalMAP programme ( http://mammalmap.adu.org.za ). The distribution of the Big Five is fairly well known but data on the SECRET SEVENTEEN would be invaluable to them.
Jeremy- this is an awesome entry. Over the summer I lived in Alaska, and had the opportunity to visit Denali National Park, which boasts their Big 5: Dall sheep, Grizzly bears, Moose, Caribou, and Gray wolves. I was fortunate to see all 5, BUT I was really excited to see the lesser knowns: ground squirrels, lynx, ptarmigan birds, golden eagles, etc. I would love to visit Africa and see the Secret Seventeen ++
ReplyDeleteThanks Alyssa. Denali sounds awesome. I'd love to get there some day.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete(Re-adding the comment with, hopefully, better spacing…)
ReplyDeleteGreat idea. Really enjoyed the post and trying to think what I would select as the Secret Seventeen!
Some of my thoughts:
* I would consider removing the following animals from the list:
- Civet (Distribution is to limited to the North of the country)
- Pangolin (Although iconic the distribution is to limited to the North of the country)
- Weasel (To small and difficult to see on game drives, etc.)
- Hedgehog (To small and difficult to see on a game drives, etc.)
- Caracal (In my opinion to common and easy to see)
* I would consider adding the following animals to the list:
- Water Mongoose (Maybe replacing the White-tailed Mongoose if you are strict about only having one mongoose)
- Bat Eared Fox (To replace the Pangolin)
- Maybe replace the Hedgehog with Hares (Scrub and Cape), they are fairly secretive, but still easy enough to see to help you get started on the list ;)
- Striped Polecat (Skunk) (As a good replacement for the African Weasel)
*I think the antelope always lose out on these lists, I’ve found some of the following to be fairly secretive and tricky to find:
- Reedbucks (Common and Mountain), even the Rhebok can be tricky to find although they are reasonably wide spread even outside protected areas.
- The Common Duiker, well maybe too common to be relevant, can be pretty secretive.
Seems like all spaces and tabs get removed once I press Publish :(
DeleteThanks Henry. I appreciate your thoughts and can't fault your preferences.
ReplyDeleteI tried in my list to have a mix of 'near-impossible' mammals as well as some that were fairly easy to see with a bit of effort. I figured that anyone setting out to see the seventeen would want a few early 'hits' but would take a significant amount of time to see them all. So I accept that some are way easier than others.
There are unfortunately always going to be mammals that don't make the list - whether its the Big Five or Secret Seventeen. Personally I'd far prefer that the Big Five included the Giraffe rather than the Buffalo. However I accept that, from a hunting perspective, the Buff is a far more serious adversary.
So, no list is going to please everyone. But what I'm keen to do is get as many replies as possible and see if any consensus emerges. I'll keep you posted.
Thanks again.
Great concept. Highlighting diversity is much more interesting than big game animals. Unfortunately, I've only seen 1 of your 17 - the African wildcat. And that was in the Okavango. For California and western North America, my 17 would include: pronghorn, coyote, bobcat, kit fox, badger, sea otter, fisher, marten, ringtail, spotted skunk, beaver, jackrabbit, pika, chipmunk, flying squirrel, woodrat, and kangaroo rat.
ReplyDeleteRandomtruth: thanks for the effort of compiling you own 17. That's really interesting.
ReplyDeleteI have to confess that I'd never heard of a Spotted Skunk - clearly us Africans need to travel more! I also wasn't familiar with a Ringtail but a Wiki search suggested it could be a Lemur, Mongoose, Possum, Cat or Squirrel. The first three don't seem to occur in North America so was it the cat or squirrel that you are referring to?
I'm glad you got to see the Okavango. It is possibly my favorite place on earth! I'm desperate to get back and do some camera-trapping there.
In NA we do have the Virginia opossum (Didelphis virginiana). I believe the ringtail is related to our Raccoon though.
DeleteAs Alyssa mentions, we do have an oppossum in North America, although it isn't native to the western states. And as she also reported, ringtails are related to our raccoons. Here's a couple of posts for ya: spotted skunk, and ringtail.
DeleteThanks Randomtruth. Those are very cool images.
Delete